Cash My Phone

I sent an old cell phone of mine in to CashMyPhone.com. I considered using SecondRotation but they didn't have that particular phone model listed on the web site so rather than send it and wait to see what they decided it was worth I just used CashMyPhone.

I got an email a few days after I sent the phone saying that they had received it. Then a couple of months later I got an email saying it had been "disqualified" and I had to pay $8 to get it back. So I replied saying please send it back to me, and no reply and no phone. A few more weeks pass and I get a "final" email warning me that if I don't request the phone back they will keep it.

I have sent it at least 4 emails to these people and have received no reply. The phone had no physical damage to it when I sent it to them. I'm starting to wonder if this whole thing is a scam - they either get $8 to ship the phone back to me or they get the whole phone for free.

Anyone have any experience with these guys? If I don't hear back by the end of the week I will file a complaint with the better business bureau.